Immoral or Unconstitutional Government Decrees :: Politics Political Essays

Immoral or Unconstitutional Government DecreesImagine this scenario and lets do a thought experiment. Im ordered by the Department of Health and Human function (DHHS) to perform, with stunned compensation, cleaning services at a local senior citizen retirement home. Ive not been found guilty in a court of right of a crime for which Im being punished. Ive simply been ordered by DHHS to massage at the senior citizen home in the name of promoting the public welfare. misadventure to comply means going to jail.I might seek a court injunction against DHHSs edit. But suppose the court ruled that DHHS had the authorization to order me to perform cleaning services at senior citizen homes. I might take my complaint all the way to the U.S. Supreme coquette only for the Court to rule yes, under the U.S. Constitutions welfare clause, and the authority it gives Congress, Im compelled as ordered by DHHS to perform cleaning services.My interrogatory to you is now that the courts select rule d, should I simply comply? You might rejoin by suggesting that the question cannot be answered unless additional information is supplied such as Did Congress aright vote to authorize DHHS to order me to clean senior citizen homes? Did DHHS single me out or are some other Americans assigned similar tasks? In other words, was there invidious discrimination?My response to your first set of questions is what does a vote claim to do with the rightness or wrongness of the DHHS sanction? Would one determine the rightness or wrongness of rape, murder, theft and thraldom by whether there was majority vote? To the second question, I would likewise ask does the rightness or wrongness of an act depend upon the sum up of people, a hundred people or cardinals of people, forcibly used to hang the purposes of another? Was slavery in our country okay because 4 million downcasts were enslaved instead of undecomposed one? Does equality in servitude make servitude just? One might rejoin by give voiceing, All those arguments are incomplete here nor there the law is the law and people should obey. I say balderdash southeastern Africa used to have apartheid laws that strictly controlled where blacks could live, work, and eat. Nazi Germany had anti-semitic laws. In United States there was the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850. Would you have obeyed those laws? Would you have approved of and sought prosecution of white employers who hired black workers in contravention of job reservation laws that were a part of South Africas Civilized Labour Policy?